CCH3900

which was the Best NHL game for the following categories:

Gameplay:
Graphics:
Sound:
Layout/Design (Overlays, Pause menu etc.):
Layout/Design (Menus):
Commentary:
Coolest Added Feature (Name it too!):
Best Feature Removed (Name it too!):
Dumbest Added Feature (Name it too!):
Poorly Developed Feature (Name it too!):
Worst Feature Removed (Name it too!):
Cover: (if athelete name him):
Intro:
Logo:
Disc Design:
Music (menu):
Music (in-game):

*PICK ONE AND ONLY ONE YEAR!
**Choices are for PC and 1991-2006 console versions only

__________________

CCH3900

Gameplay: NHL08
Graphics: NHL06
Sound: NHL06
Layout/Design (Overlays, Pause menu etc.): NHL08
Layout/Design (Menus): NHL 2000
Commentary: NHL06 (NHL 2002, close second)
Coolest Added Feature (Name it too!): NHL 2004: Dynasty Mode
Best Feature Removed (Name it too!): NHL07: Skill Stick
Dumbest Added Feature (Name it too!): NHL06: Skill Stick
Poorly Developed Feature (Name it too!): NHL 2005: Free-4-All
Worst Feature Removed (Name it too!): NHL 2001: Practice/Tutorial Mode
Cover: (if athelete name him): NHL 2005: Markus Naslund
Intro: NHL 99
Logo: NHL 98
Disc Design: NHL06
Music (menu): NHL 2000
Music (in-game): NHL 2003

__________________

SugarKane

Gameplay: NHL 2004
Graphics: NHL 2004 (haven't seen 05 and 06)
Sound: NHL 2002
Layout/Design (Overlays, Pause menu etc.): NHL 2002
Layout/Design (Menus): NHL 2002
Commentary: NHL 2002 (last time in german with a german player as co)
Coolest Added Feature (Name it too!): Playercards in NHL 2002
Best Feature Removed (Name it too!): Player statistics sheet columns to wide, so that you needed to scroll one column right to see the total points of a player - last (only?) version where it was perfect was NHL 2000
Cover: (if athelete name him): NHL 2003 (Jarome Iginla)
Intro: NHL 2000
Logo:
Disc Design: no idea, never looked at it closely
Music (menu): NHL 2002
Music (in-game): NHL 2002

Bye,
Kane

__________________

Eugene Power

Gameplay: 04
Graphics: 06
Sound: euh 06 ??
Layout/Design (Overlays, Pause menu etc.): don't remember but 04 I think
Layout/Design (Menus): 04 of course
Commentary: 06
Coolest Added Feature (Name it too!): manual deke in 04 not 03
Best Feature Removed (Name it too!): manual deke of 03
Cover: (if athelete name him): Heatley 04 close second Forsberg 98
Intro: 98 with 99 close behind
Logo: 97
Disc Design: they're all ugly
Music (menu): 03
Music (in-game): 03

__________________

¥~{£µGèÑé-ÞøWë®}~¥

BashBrothers

Gameplay: 06
Graphics: 08
Sound:06
Layout/Design (Overlays, Pause menu etc.):08
Layout/Design (Menus):08
Commentary:08
Coolest Added Feature (Name it too!):08 Dynasty Mode with Fantasy Draft
Best Feature Removed (Name it too!):
Cover: (if athelete name him): 03 Iginla
Intro:98
Logo:08/07
Disc Design:98
Music (menu):06
Music (in-game):06

PrImEaU25

Gameplay: 08
Graphics: 08
Sound: 06
Layout/Design (Overlays, Pause menu etc.): 05
Layout/Design (Menus): 05
Commentary: 2002 and BY MUCH
Coolest Added Feature (Name it too!): 2002 : Player Cards
WORST Feature Removed (Name it too!): Player Creating . Big mistake
Cover: (if athelete name him): 2002 Lemieux
Intro: 2004
Logo: 08
Disc Design: 04
Music (menu): 2004
Music (in-game): 2002

__________________
. Facepack Maker .
Listen to my friend's songs at http://www.myspace.com/fullinfekted

TrueFlames24

hmm I'll have to go back into my brain

Gameplay: NHL 2004
Graphics:2006/7/8 (since they are all the same)
Sound: 2004...'that save was of the OBtuse angle'...Jim:YOU're of the obtuse angle
Layout/Design (Overlays, Pause menu etc.): 2007
Layout/Design (Menus):2004
Commentary:2002
Coolest Added Feature (Name it too!):skill stick
Best Feature Removed (Name it too!): The create-a-player in 2005, that pretty much killed the franchise
Cover: (if athelete name him): Iginla 2003
Intro: NHL 99 hands down (gives me chills everytime)
Logo:NHL 2001 was pretty sweet
Disc Design: The one with Vanbiesbroucks mask on it..I think it was NHL 98
Music (menu): 2004
Music (in-game):NHL 2002 hands down with the slowmo music and such

__________________
FLAMES IN 08

CCH3900

Edited my choices, and topic rules, and NEW selections

__________________

pokkai

Gameplay: NHL 2004
Graphics: NHL 08
Sound: NHL 2001
Layout/Design (Overlays, Pause menu etc.): NHL 2000
Layout/Design (Menus): NHL 2001
Commentary: NHL 2001
Coolest Added Feature (Name it too!): NHL 08 Skill Stick
Best Feature Removed (Name it too!): Edit lines menu from NHL 2000
Dumbest Added Feature (Name it too!): NHL 06 Skill Stick
Poorly Developed Feature (Name it too!): NHL 2005 Free 4 All
Worst Feature Removed (Name it too!): NHL 06 Skill Stick
Cover: (if athelete name him): NHL 2005 Nazzy
Intro: NHL 99
Logo: NHL 2001
Disc Design: Dunno they all suck
Music (menu): NHL 2000
Music (in-game): NHL 2004

Prestilence

Gameplay: NHL 2004
Graphics: NHL 06
Sound: NHL 2004
Layout/Design (Overlays, Pause menu etc.): NHL 2004
Layout/Design (Menus): NHL 99 (video menus)
Commentary: NHL 2004
Coolest Added Feature (Name it too!): mask viewer/player highlight reels (NHL97), holding pass button to determine pass strength (NHL 2004)
Best Feature that EA Removed (Name it too!): mask viewer/player highlight reels (NHL97), holding pass button to determine pass strength (NHL 2004)
Dumbest Added Feature (Name it too!): having console menus/edit lines for PC users. skill stick.
Poorly Developed Feature (Name it too!):AI (NHL06), Practice mode/goalie injuries(where are they???)
Worst Feature that EA Removed (Name it too!): Saving Highlights/Replays
Cover: (if athelete name him): Pronger (NHL2000)
Intro:tie NHL 1999 and NHL 2000, equally good.
Logo: irrelevant/dont care
Disc Design: irrelevant/dont care/same as cover
Music (menu): NHL 2002
Music (in-game): NHL 2002

Played all NHL games from NHL94 except 05,07,08. All PC.